Survivor: Cagayan

[Caryn]

Moving this thread from Crashcourse over to Stranded.

And I swear to fucking god if you move this to my corner I'm going to be livid pissed. This isn't just some random post, this is a social thread for EVERYONE to discuss.

[Mia]

having to pick between Spencer/J'Tia is so unfair </3

[Gabriel]

I KNOW. The Brains tribe is literally the worst tribe but I just wanted them all to stay. I love all of them.

I think they made the right decision though. I wish Spencer would've fought a little more instead of just giving a measly "please don't vote me out" but he ended up staying anyway.

Seeing J'Tia struggle so hard in the water was literally so frustrating

[Caryn]

LOL J'Tia has to be the worst Survivor player of all time.

Spencer is soo going to flip on Tasha/Kass with the swap.

[General]

Brain were my favorite tribe. I'm so mad they got decimated

[Ben]

Brain were my favorite tribe. I'm so mad they got decimated

Not yet! There's still hope!

[Frank]

Yay she's finally gone, I never seen someone suck so bad lol

Spencer If he flips on those bitches and makes an alliance with LJ and Tony this will seriously be my favorite season ever.

[Gabriel]

It's so fun to hate them. Like I want them gone (LJ & Tony) in the sense that the show wouldn't be as good if they left. Soooo idk what to think

[Mia]

Yay she's finally gone, I never seen someone suck so bad lol

Spencer If he flips on those bitches and makes an alliance with LJ and Tony this will seriously be my favorite season ever.

ew why would you say those words

[Lurker_Rachel]

Seriously, I'm just glad Spencer is at least getting a chance to play.

[Brenda]

I'm a Tony fan.

Also Sarah, Kass, Woo!, Alexis, Morgan, Tasha.

Meh to the rest.

[Caryn]

Brenda, not having Spencer on your list of favorites is a SIN.


Impromptu Cast Ranking:

14. Jefra
13. Jeremiah
12. Trish
11. Sarah
10. Lindsey
9. Cliff
8. LJ
7. Alexis
6. WOO!
5. Kass
4. Morgan
3. Tony
2. Spencer
1. Tasha

This is based on the first 3 (Or 4, whichever way you see it) episodes.


And:

4. David
3. Garrett
2. Brice
1. J'Tia


DOT DOT DOT, HMMMMMMM.

[Brenda]

idk, I don't see what Spencer has actually done? I didn't particularly like J'Tia but I'd have her above him too. He was just quiet and useful and not insane. The best thing I can say about him is, he's not as bad as his pre-show made him out to be - but there's time yet :D

dislike
Jeremiah/Lindsey/Trish/Jefra

tolerate
LJ/Spencer

potential
Cliffy

like
Tasha/Woo/Alexis/Morgan

love
Tony/Sarah/Kass

[Gabriel]

LOVE Jefra, Lindsey, Sarah, Morgan, Tasha, Alexis, Tony, & Spencer

HATE Kass, Woo, Cliff, LJ, Trish, & Jeremiah

Which of course love and hate are strong words but as it stands now, that's how the cookie crumbles. I see Tony making it pretty far and Spencer is only in the love part of the list b/c he was really easy to root for and I'm excited to see what he can do other than get pissed at J'Tia and shoot balls into water baskets

Love the amount of drama Morgan is looking to stir up.

And Jefra is in my love list because we're both from Kentucky and she's standing out as the dumb blonde pageant girl who doesn't want to be perceived as such but is doing everything to make people perceive her as such

[Brenda]

Who could hate Woo! ? (yes it's pronounced with the exclamation mark always on).

[Caryn]

Sarah is nothing but a zombie to me now. She's getting played like a fiddle and I feel embarrassed for her.

Coming in I thought Woo! was just going to find an alliance and just blindly follow them throughout the game, but he actually has strategy going up in his head. He realizes Cliff is not in the majority and is willing to cut him loose when the opportunity presents itself.

And it's kind of sad that the most athletic player there just so happens to be the skinny pasty white kid on the Brains tribe.

[Gabriel]

Like I said, hate is a strong word but I used it just so that it would fit nicely with love, lol. I'm not like against Woo! or anything but he's just not a favorite of mine. I typically never root for the athletic guy who is also smart (like Malcolm in recent years) and it's not that I think they're playing a bad game, I just don't ever find myself caring if they're in the game or not. Idk, sorta weird

[Mia]

Brenda loves J'Tia RIGHT?

[Lurker_Rachel]

J'Tia was a lovable trainwreck.

[Brenda]

Brenda loves J'Tia RIGHT?

Love is a strong word. Let's just say she was good value for her time there, and it was the right time for her to leave.

You can say the first part for all four boots so far actually, which is good for the Season. Would have liked to see Brice hang around a little longer.