Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Re: Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Postby Sophie » Sun Apr 13, 2014 10:34:19 pm

A Gay, A Bitch, and a Swingster
All of my questions will be bolded. Anything else with a question mark that is not bolded you should not answer

Well, congratulations to you three for making it this far. I have to get that out of the way first because everyone who makes it to the final three deserves praise since they played better games than EVERY single person that didn't make it there. I am a firm believer in that, and think that although I was playing a better game than you all at the time when I was there, I clearly didn't in the long run since I was voted out. I do believe that you all played very different games, and all got here in different ways. Some were much more noble and worthy of a vote than others, and that's what we are going to have to figure out tonight. My goal with these statements and comments to you all is to figure out who I am voting for, because at this point I have absolutely no clue. It is between two people for my vote, but a third could come out of the blue and wow me. This game started as nine ra-ra-reds and nine blue-bleeders, and in the end you three blue-bleeders are the ones that made it to the place where we now judge you. So without further ado, I'll begin the bashfest and figure out who deserves to win this game.
Image

Stephanie-Hey gurl :) So everyone knows that the three main elements of the game Stranded is the social, strategic, and physical aspects. I think you have one of the cleanest games ever, and you didn't really piss anyone off like I did or really ever be that honest with people. Should you have? Well, in my opinion I think if you had you would have had my vote on lock for you. But whatever, that's your problem now. Socially you were fake girl, and I mean really fake. You would send messages that had paragraphs of content, but yet all they did was repeat what I had already said and give vague-ass statements. Do you really think that's worthy of my vote? Physically and strategically I think you were pretty commanding, but also boring at times. I think that it was very easy to excel strategically for you since you were working side by side with one of the biggest goats in Stranded history. But Physically you rocked, and you won challenges when your neck was on the line and you also found idols like a mad-woman. So my hats are off to you darling, because you definitely played a great game but I don't know if it is one I really want to vote for. After all, this isn't just about gameplay. I have to feel GOOD about voting for whoever I do, and I can't say I am completely feel-good about writing your name down on a piece of paper yet. I may have said this before, but I feel like you are very fake all the time. It just is upsetting that if I do vote for you, I am voting for a fake bitch instead of a great bitch. icon_sleeping
Image

Mike-Oh boy Mike, this is not going to be pretty for you tonight lmao. I think you were a sweet kid with a lot of potential in the beginning, but I had a feeling from the moment I saw you in tribal forums that you were a little bit of an aloof princess. Unfortunately, you never proved me wrong at ALL which is not my problem any more. It is YOUR problem since you are in the final three. You floated behind Stephanie, and socially you were awful to me. I always tried to engage you in conversation and I always tried to make you feel alright with me, but you were so awful at responding. I would message you after a round, and you would take an entire day to get back to me which was just absolutely awful. Physically, woopty-do you won a challenge. Congratulations on that, but that doesn't get you any credit with me since it was just one challenge and you weren't in jeopardy anyway. Nobody ever wanted to vote you out since you were such an easy goat to take to the end. Why do you think we voted for you on the first merge council here? We KNEW that you would not have an idol at all since you were so hopeless, and also that people actually pretended you were the leader just to appease you. It's hilarious really that you are sitting here, and I hope you know that you are not here because of your own reasons. You are here because people carried you here, and nobody ever wanted to get rid of you since you are such an easy person to go up against. Good luck tonight, you're going to need it. And another thing buddy, Sherri Bietham called. She wants her goat strategy back.
Image

David-Woah man, I never thought I would say this but I am thrilled that you are in the final three. You played a commanding game and made moves when you had to, and I have a lot of reason to write your name down tonight with a very nice comment. However, I have my hesitations as well as to whether or not I want to vote for you tonight. My problem with you really consists of your overall wish-washiness and your absolutely insulting performance at the F5 tribal council. Do you remember when you said publicly "I'm sorry Mike, I'm voting for you" or something like that? Do you remember that, because I do, and it was an absolute load of shit. If you are going to vote for me, either say that or shut the hell up and keep your mouth closed. You didn't need to lie, and if you actually were swayed by the jury faces than you are INSANE and not worthy of a single vote at all. Strategically, you were great and you made moves when you had to and your game was at risk. I think Steph and Mike think you are the goat in this situation, but I think that you have a good chance of winning this thing as long as you don't cave in at all tonight. I need to see the fire from you, and I need to see why you really deserve this title. I'd say that you hands down played the best social game as well, since you responded promptly and were not fake (*Cough Stephanie*) or annoying (*Cough Mike*). The social aspect is a huge part of this game, and you rocked it in terms of who you are sitting next to. Your game was pretty good David, but I don't know if I can vote for such a nuclear person.
Image

*Tasks*
Answer honestly, and if I catch a whiff of bullshit you lose my vote
Mike-I want you to tell me right now why those two people next to you are COMPLETELY undeserving of my vote tonight. I want you to tell me why they are hands down worse than you, and why you should win in a 9-0 landslide. This isn't a question, but do it anyway please :)
David-There are 12 people that made it to the merge, and I want you to tell me what tribe (Brain, Brawn, Beauty) EACH person would fit in to. I'd like you to give a brief summary of why you would put each person where they are, and I would love it if you would put four people per tribe to make things even and everything.
Stephanie-Like I said before, I am not sold on you like one particular Jury member is, so I need more from you. I want you to tell me why MIKE is more deserving SPECIFICALLY than you. I need you to give good reasons and not hesitant ones, and the more you give me the more I may be inclined to vote for you.
Good luck you all!
User avatar
Sophie
Alumni
 
Posts: 846
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2014 10:48:30 am

Re: Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Postby Grant » Sun Apr 13, 2014 10:36:02 pm

Stephanie wrote: I think overall I was the most connected person on Ovambo.


icon_whistling icon_whistling
User avatar
Grant
Alumni
 
Posts: 640
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2014 10:44:41 am

Re: Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Postby Stephanie » Sun Apr 13, 2014 10:38:42 pm

Sophie wrote:*Tasks*
Answer honestly, and if I catch a whiff of bullshit you lose my vote
Mike-I want you to tell me right now why those two people next to you are COMPLETELY undeserving of my vote tonight. I want you to tell me why they are hands down worse than you, and why you should win in a 9-0 landslide. This isn't a question, but do it anyway please :)
David-There are 12 people that made it to the merge, and I want you to tell me what tribe (Brain, Brawn, Beauty) EACH person would fit in to. I'd like you to give a brief summary of why you would put each person where they are, and I would love it if you would put four people per tribe to make things even and everything.
Stephanie-Like I said before, I am not sold on you like one particular Jury member is, so I need more from you. I want you to tell me why MIKE is more deserving SPECIFICALLY than you. I need you to give good reasons and not hesitant ones, and the more you give me the more I may be inclined to vote for you.
Good luck you all!

Hi Soph! icon_smile

Just to be clear, this is the only part you want us to answer? I don't see any bolded questions in the earlier part.
User avatar
Stephanie
Alumni
 
Posts: 9342
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2014 10:47:02 am

Re: Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Postby Sophie » Sun Apr 13, 2014 10:40:00 pm

This is the part, sorry! Lol, yes Stephanie (Wording was off for the bolded task, but yes do those!)
User avatar
Sophie
Alumni
 
Posts: 846
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2014 10:48:30 am

Re: Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Postby Ashley » Sun Apr 13, 2014 10:40:51 pm

Thanks Steph. Thanks Mike.

For anyone interested - those PMs related to me having told Mike at F4 that I had in fact voted for him at the first TC after merge, not no-voted like I told everyone on Ovambo.

Again Ralph - sorry for fucking up your game :P
User avatar
Ashley
Alumni
 
Posts: 7946
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2014 10:46:13 am

Re: Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Postby Stephanie » Sun Apr 13, 2014 10:41:21 pm

Grant wrote:
Stephanie wrote: I think overall I was the most connected person on Ovambo.


icon_whistling icon_whistling

Idk what that's supposed to mean. icon_unsure

I certainly was more connected than Mike/David. I was at the top of the bootlist at the merge, so I think that's a fair argument. I always made an effort to even talk to Ralph/Julie, and they admitted that they appreciate I always sent them length PMs getting a feel of where they're at in the game, when the others didn't give them the same attention. I would say perhaps you or perhaps Kristina are the only ones who could compare to me in that regard? But I'm up against Mike/David.
User avatar
Stephanie
Alumni
 
Posts: 9342
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2014 10:47:02 am

Re: Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Postby Grant » Sun Apr 13, 2014 10:41:59 pm

Mike wrote:Reading over them again he actually definitely is a really great guy. Trust me on it :)


icon_blush
User avatar
Grant
Alumni
 
Posts: 640
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2014 10:44:41 am

Re: Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Postby Ashley » Sun Apr 13, 2014 10:51:16 pm

like one particular Jury member is


icon_lol icon_lol icon_lol icon_lol
User avatar
Ashley
Alumni
 
Posts: 7946
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2014 10:46:13 am

Re: Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Postby Stephanie » Sun Apr 13, 2014 10:54:36 pm

Hi Soph!

To answer your question, Mike deserves to win over me because:

*He was perceived as a bigger target than me, for the first half of the merge. He almost got voted out at the merge, it was a 6-5 vote. I wasn't on anyone's radar.
*Again, at Final 8, he was your primary target until he won immunity, not me. At this time, he was perceived as a bigger threat as well.
*He was on the outs early on in Ovambo. He was literally the last one to show up, and was voted as "least trustworthy" because of it. So in a way I think he had more to "overcome" than me after not being included in the initial "big" alliance of six, of me/Kristina/Julie/Ralph/Grant/David.
*He went to rocks at Final 6, even though I was willing to go to rocks for Kristina, I never had to, due to David flipping.
*I was immune from Final 7 onwards. It's true I earned it, but Mike was vulnerable for all of those votes.
*I guess he was more genuine/blunt with you than I was. You say I was "fake", to an extent I was, but I did like you on a personal level, despite us not being on the same side as you for the majority of the game. I was honest with you about targeting you in those later rounds, earlier in the merge, but I honestly did want you around until at least Final 5/6. I wanted to play with the "big guns" and test myself. However, I never really had any intention of going to the end with you, like I'm sure you didn't with me. I think Mike was probably more genuine about where he stood with you, and perhaps some others too.

Good luck with your decision! icon_smile
User avatar
Stephanie
Alumni
 
Posts: 9342
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2014 10:47:02 am

Re: Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Postby Stephanie » Sun Apr 13, 2014 10:55:42 pm

Stephanie wrote:*He went to rocks at Final 6, even though I was willing to go to rocks for Kristina, I never had to, due to David flipping.

*Final 7.
User avatar
Stephanie
Alumni
 
Posts: 9342
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2014 10:47:02 am

Re: Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Postby David » Sun Apr 13, 2014 10:57:39 pm

This is gonna be fun! Also, am I the gay, bitch, or swingster??
I'm gonna try and make this as even as possible.
Beauty:
Whitney - She didn't play the most brainy or brawny game, but I can't help but fall for a gorgeous southern blonde with a great voice <3 lol
Mike - I feel like he relied on his social game above all, especially early on, which meant I had to classify him as a beauty. Also, you can ask Ashley about my feelings on him! :)
Ashley - Coming into the game meant she had to get into the good graces of the leaders of the Nama tribe, which indicates a great social game in my mind.
Ralph - Everyone liked Ralph! Especially when he was on his drunken tirades at tribal.
Brain
Cochran - He seemed like a smart fellow. I don't think he was great at challenges, and this tribe seems like the best place for him.
Kristina - One of my first confessionals was about how Kristina seemed so smart and self aware. Seems like I was right.
Julie - I was rude to Julie a few times, but I think she did such a good job at making us underestimate her. Like we all said, no one suspected for a second that Julie would flip.
David - I'm not ready to pretend that I'm stupid. I feel like I made smart decisions most of the time. Also, I definitely don't see myself as a brawn or beauty.
Brawn
Papa Bear - Can't really classify him as anything else. I think he did do well in premerge challenges though, so there's that....
Grant - He won the first two challenges after the merge, and was just a beast in general.
Sophie - Did good in every challenge no matter what it was. Every challenge, we had to make up a backup plan for if Sophie won immunity, which is pretty telling.
Stephanie - Same as Sophie. Did well in every single challenge. Also, stayed up for like 11 hours, which is pretty impressive
User avatar
David
Alumni
 
Posts: 1432
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2014 10:44:15 am

Re: Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Postby Sophie » Sun Apr 13, 2014 10:57:58 pm

*He went to rocks at Final 6, even though I was willing to go to rocks for Kristina, I never had to, due to David flipping.


icon_glare
~
Thanks Stephanie for the response, and actually being fast unlike these slow fucks who are making us stay up so late.
User avatar
Sophie
Alumni
 
Posts: 846
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2014 10:48:30 am

Re: Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Postby Sophie » Sun Apr 13, 2014 10:59:29 pm

David wrote:This is gonna be fun! Also, am I the gay, bitch, or swingster??
I'm gonna try and make this as even as possible.
Beauty:
Whitney - She didn't play the most brainy or brawny game, but I can't help but fall for a gorgeous southern blonde with a great voice <3 lol
Mike - I feel like he relied on his social game above all, especially early on, which meant I had to classify him as a beauty. Also, you can ask Ashley about my feelings on him! :)
Ashley - Coming into the game meant she had to get into the good graces of the leaders of the Nama tribe, which indicates a great social game in my mind.
Ralph - Everyone liked Ralph! Especially when he was on his drunken tirades at tribal.
Brain
Cochran - He seemed like a smart fellow. I don't think he was great at challenges, and this tribe seems like the best place for him.
Kristina - One of my first confessionals was about how Kristina seemed so smart and self aware. Seems like I was right.
Julie - I was rude to Julie a few times, but I think she did such a good job at making us underestimate her. Like we all said, no one suspected for a second that Julie would flip.
David - I'm not ready to pretend that I'm stupid. I feel like I made smart decisions most of the time. Also, I definitely don't see myself as a brawn or beauty.
Brawn
Papa Bear - Can't really classify him as anything else. I think he did do well in premerge challenges though, so there's that....
Grant - He won the first two challenges after the merge, and was just a beast in general.
Sophie - Did good in every challenge no matter what it was. Every challenge, we had to make up a backup plan for if Sophie won immunity, which is pretty telling.
Stephanie - Same as Sophie. Did well in every single challenge. Also, stayed up for like 11 hours, which is pretty impressive


Thank you David! I didn't think you would excel in this question, but I love your responses and reasonings for each person :)

And also, you are the swingster of course!
User avatar
Sophie
Alumni
 
Posts: 846
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2014 10:48:30 am

Re: Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Postby Ralph » Sun Apr 13, 2014 10:59:59 pm

icon_wub
David wrote:This is gonna be fun! Also, am I the gay, bitch, or swingster??
I'm gonna try and make this as even as possible.
Beauty:
Whitney - She didn't play the most brainy or brawny game, but I can't help but fall for a gorgeous southern blonde with a great voice <3 lol
Mike - I feel like he relied on his social game above all, especially early on, which meant I had to classify him as a beauty. Also, you can ask Ashley about my feelings on him! :)
Ashley - Coming into the game meant she had to get into the good graces of the leaders of the Nama tribe, which indicates a great social game in my mind.
Ralph - Everyone liked Ralph! Especially when he was on his drunken tirades at tribal.
Brain
Cochran - He seemed like a smart fellow. I don't think he was great at challenges, and this tribe seems like the best place for him.
Kristina - One of my first confessionals was about how Kristina seemed so smart and self aware. Seems like I was right.
Julie - I was rude to Julie a few times, but I think she did such a good job at making us underestimate her. Like we all said, no one suspected for a second that Julie would flip.
David - I'm not ready to pretend that I'm stupid. I feel like I made smart decisions most of the time. Also, I definitely don't see myself as a brawn or beauty.
Brawn
Papa Bear - Can't really classify him as anything else. I think he did do well in premerge challenges though, so there's that....
Grant - He won the first two challenges after the merge, and was just a beast in general.
Sophie - Did good in every challenge no matter what it was. Every challenge, we had to make up a backup plan for if Sophie won immunity, which is pretty telling.
Stephanie - Same as Sophie. Did well in every single challenge. Also, stayed up for like 11 hours, which is pretty impressive
User avatar
Ralph
Alumni
 
Posts: 273
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2014 10:42:51 am

Re: Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Postby Grant » Sun Apr 13, 2014 11:00:20 pm

David wrote:Grant - He won the first two challenges after the merge, and was just a beast in general.


THREE icon_mad icon_mad
User avatar
Grant
Alumni
 
Posts: 640
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2014 10:44:41 am

Re: Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Postby Grant » Sun Apr 13, 2014 11:00:20 pm

David wrote:Grant - He won the first two challenges after the merge, and was just a beast in general.


THREE icon_mad icon_mad
User avatar
Grant
Alumni
 
Posts: 640
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2014 10:44:41 am

Re: Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Postby Ashley » Sun Apr 13, 2014 11:00:20 pm

Beauty/Brain hybrid obvs *flicks hair disdainfully*
User avatar
Ashley
Alumni
 
Posts: 7946
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2014 10:46:13 am

Re: Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Postby Ashley » Sun Apr 13, 2014 11:01:34 pm

Sophie wrote:
And also, you are the swingster of course!



EUEUUEUEUGGGGH GUESS AGAIN lol

icon_lol
User avatar
Ashley
Alumni
 
Posts: 7946
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2014 10:46:13 am

Re: Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Postby Sophie » Sun Apr 13, 2014 11:01:45 pm

Grant wrote:
David wrote:Grant - He won the first two challenges after the merge, and was just a beast in general.


THREE icon_mad icon_mad


Same thing pretty much. Not like the third one got you to the final three :P
User avatar
Sophie
Alumni
 
Posts: 846
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2014 10:48:30 am

Re: Day 30 - Final Tribal Council

Postby David » Sun Apr 13, 2014 11:02:36 pm

Ashley wrote:
Sophie wrote:
And also, you are the swingster of course!



EUEUUEUEUGGGGH GUESS AGAIN lol

icon_lol

Omg, lol. I guess I'm just a combo of all three! icon_biggrin
User avatar
David
Alumni
 
Posts: 1432
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2014 10:44:15 am

PreviousNext

Return to Tribal Council

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 13 guests
cron